# Theme evaluation scorecard

Theme: __________  Version: __________  Reviewer: __________

Score each item from 1 (poor) to 5 (excellent). Add evidence and any unresolved questions.

| Criterion | Score | Evidence / notes |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Fits representative real content and products | | |
| Editors can maintain key pages | | |
| Keyboard and mobile navigation | | |
| Contrast, labels and accessible controls | | |
| Performance with realistic content | | |
| Plugin or app compatibility | | |
| Support, updates and documentation | | |
| License and ongoing cost | | |

Critical blockers: __________
Migration and rollback plan: __________
Recommendation and tradeoffs: __________